No Mentor? No Problem
Guest Post By Lois Kirkpatrick, MBA
In my opinion, the jury’s still out on the value of business mentors.
I realize I’m in the minority with this opinion. According to Forbes, 84% of Fortune 500 companies have mentoring programs. But if you ask the CEOs of top companies what led to their own success, few will mention being mentored.
Take this business.com article “Dose of Motivation: 52 Inspirational Quotes About Success by Influential CEOs.” Current and former corporate leaders Sara Blakely (Spanx), Marissa Mayer (Yahoo), Denise Morrison (Campbell Soup) and Ellen Kullman (DuPont) never mention having been mentored as a key to their success.
There are so many factors that contribute to professional success. Talent, drive, people skills, luck, timing, and so much more. What led to one person’s success might be something that can’t be reproduced by the person they’re mentoring.
In the Gallup Workplace article “Mentors Aren’t Enough: What Women Need to Advance,” author Kristin Barry writes that mentors “listen, provide support and trust, coach, and share advice based on their own experience.” The key here is the phrase, “based on their own experience.”
The person being mentored can never replicate the mentor’s experience. The mentor probably started their career in different market conditions. Or in a different economy. Or in an organization with a different culture.
They had different personalities that might have meshed with bygone leadership better than their protege’s personality will sync with the current C-suite occupants.
It might have worked for the mentor to do X, but it could be the exact opposite thing that will work for the protege.
These being the facts, the best a mentor can offer is to be a professional sounding board. But they can’t lay out a roadmap that’s guaranteed to get you to where you want to go. The good news is, like countless others who have gone before, you can still achieve success without participating in a professional mentoring relationship. So, no mentor? No problem.
About the Author
Lois Kirkpatrick currently directs a project management office, and has more than a decade of experience managing communication teams.







